Please find our Newsflash on “Delhi ITAT: Buy-back of Shares Held to Constitute Corporate Reorganisation under Article 13(5) of the India-Netherlands DTAA”.
The Delhi ITAT examined whether capital gains arising to a Netherlands-based parent company from the buy-back of shares by its Indian subsidiary qualified for treaty protection under Article 13(5) of the India-Netherlands DTAA.
The key highlights of the ruling are as follows:
• A buy-back of shares may constitute a “corporate reorganisation” under Article 13(5), particularly where it forms part of an intra-group capital restructuring.
• The expression “corporate reorganisation” should be interpreted purposively and is not restricted to conventional transactions such as mergers, amalgamations or demergers.
• The procedure adopted for implementing the buy-back does not, by itself, alter the true character of the transaction.
• The prescribed ownership conditions under Article 13(5) were satisfied, as the Netherlands parent held substantially more than 10% of the capital of the Indian subsidiary.
• Following a difference of opinion between the Accountant Member and the Judicial Member, the Third Member agreed with the Accountant Member and held that the gains were taxable exclusively in the Netherlands. Accordingly, the assessee’s appeal was allowed.
• Protocols to comparable tax treaties, judicial precedents and professional guidance may be considered as supplementary aids while interpreting undefined treaty expressions.
The ruling is relevant for multinational groups undertaking intra-group buy-backs and other capital restructuring transactions. However, the availability of treaty protection would depend upon the specific language of the applicable tax treaty, the transaction structure and satisfaction of the prescribed conditions.
We hope you find the attached Newsflash useful.
Click here to download-RSM India Newsflash: Delhi ITAT: Buy-back of Shares Held to Constitute Corporate Reorganisation under Article 13(5) of the India-Netherlands DTAA