1. What are Ancillary Taxes: Basic Overview and Role

Ancillary taxes are additional taxes levied on top of the principal tax amount that is originally due. They are imposed as a penalty when a taxpayer fails to file a final tax return by the due date or fails to pay taxes by the payment deadline.

In Japan's national tax system, there are six types of ancillary taxes: delinquency tax, interest tax, additional tax for underpayment, additional tax for non-filing, additional tax for non-payment of withholding tax, and heavy additional tax. All of these are levied to encourage taxpayers to file and pay their taxes properly and on time.

Ancillary taxes are structured such that if there is an under-declaration or late payment, an additional tax burden arises separate from the principal tax. For businesses, avoiding these ancillary taxes as much as possible is crucial for sound management.
 

2. Types and Rates of Ancillary Taxes in Japan (National Taxes)

Japan's ancillary tax system comprises the six types mentioned above, each with defined conditions for imposition and tax rates. The types and overviews of ancillary taxes are summarized below:

1.) Delinquency Tax (遅延税 - Entaizei):

This is a tax equivalent to interest on overdue payments. If taxes are not paid in full by the due date, delinquency tax is calculated daily from the day following the statutory due date until the day of full payment. The annual rate of delinquency tax varies by period: up to 7.3% per annum for the period within two months from the deadline, and increasing to up to 14.6% per annum after two months.

2.) Additional Tax for Underpayment (過少申告加算税 - Kashō Shinkoku Kasenzei):

This is a penalty for under-declared taxes resulting from an audit assessment. It is imposed when a return was filed on time but contained errors, leading to additional tax payments through an amended return or reassessment. As a general rule, 10% of the additional tax amount due is levied. Furthermore, for the portion of the additional tax amount that exceeds "the tax amount reported in the original timely filed return or JPY 500,000, whichever is greater," an additional 5% is imposed.

3.) Additional Tax for Non-filing (無申告加算税 - Mushinkoku Kasenzei):

This is a penalty imposed in addition to the principal tax when a tax return is not submitted by the due date (i.e., failure to file or forgetting to file). The tax rate, as a general rule, is progressively applied to the principal tax amount due: 15% for the portion up to JPY 500,000, 20% for the portion exceeding JPY 500,000 up to JPY 3,000,000, and 30% for the portion exceeding JPY 3,000,000.

4.) Additional Tax for Non-payment of Withholding Tax (不納付加算税 - Funōfu Kasenzei):

This ancillary tax is imposed when withheld taxes are not paid by the statutory due date. 10% of the tax amount due is levied, but if paid voluntarily before receiving a notice from the tax office, the rate is reduced to 5%. While it's easy to overlook withholding tax payments, it's important to remember that prompt voluntary payment can halve the penalty rate.

5.) Heavy Additional Tax (重加算税 - Jūkasenzei):

This is a very severe penalty imposed in cases of malicious disguise or concealment regarding any of the above additional tax situations. Specifically, if there was intentional income concealment or similar acts, 35% of the principal tax is levied in lieu of the additional tax for underpayment or additional tax for non-payment of withholding tax, and 40% in lieu of the additional tax for non-filing. Furthermore, if heavy additional tax or additional tax for non-filing was imposed within the past five years, the tax rate is increased by an additional 10%.

6.) Interest Tax (利子税 - Rishizei):

This is a tax akin to interest, imposed for periods when a payment deadline has been officially extended through procedures approved by the tax office, such as tax deferral. Due to its nature of deferring payment based on a prior application, a relatively lower interest rate is set.
 

These are the types and rates of ancillary taxes under Japan's national tax system. While the Japanese ancillary tax system is meticulously categorized, it consistently incorporates incentives to encourage "voluntary proper filing and payment." It also has mechanisms where certain relief measures can be received if corrections are made early, even after the deadline.

3. Ancillary Tax Systems in Major Countries and Their Differences

Other countries also have penalty systems for under-declarations or late payments, but their content and severity vary significantly by nation.

Let's examine the ancillary tax systems in the United States and Singapore.

[Ancillary Tax System in the United States]

U.S. tax law sets clear penalties for delayed filing and payment. First, if a return is not filed by the deadline, corporations not electing pass-through taxation are generally subject to a penalty of 5% of the unpaid tax for each month or part of a month the return is late, up to a maximum of 25% (five months). For late payments, a penalty of 0.5% of the unpaid tax is typically imposed per month or part of a month, also with a maximum of 25%.

In addition to this, interest accrues on underpayments. The interest rate fluctuates annually and is characteristically determined based on short-term interest rates. For underpayment, a penalty of 20% of the underpayment is imposed. This applies to under-declarations due to negligence or calculation errors. If intentional tax evasion is determined, a very severe penalty of 75% of the underpayment is imposed.

[Ancillary Tax System in Singapore]
Singapore's ancillary tax system for corporate income tax is stringent and carries high rates. First, for late filing or non-filing, a surcharge or fine of up to 200% of the undeclared tax, and potentially imprisonment, may be imposed.

For late payment, a 5% penalty is levied, and if the payment remains outstanding, an additional 1% is added each month. In cases of under-declaration, penalties of up to 400% or criminal charges may apply depending on the intent, with particularly severe penalties for deliberate tax evasion.

All countries have mechanisms to impose financial disadvantages through fines, delinquency taxes, and additional taxes to encourage timely and accurate filing and payment.
 

4. Impact of Ancillary Taxes on Corporate Management

Ancillary taxes are additional costs levied separately from the principal tax, and thus have a significant impact on a company's finances and management. From a cash flow perspective, unexpected cash outflows due to reassessments and delinquency taxes strain cash flow. This may sometimes necessitate additional fundraising or force the company to draw down funds originally intended for business investments.

Furthermore, the existence of ancillary taxes is a tax risk in itself. For a company's CFO, being notified of an under-declaration during a tax audit means not only an additional tax burden but also substantial payments including penalties and delinquency interest. In addition, companies with a history of serious violations, such as heavy additional tax, are more likely to be specifically targeted by tax authorities, potentially leading to increased frequency and extended duration of future tax audits, continuously increasing the burden on management and the accounting department.

In summary, ancillary taxes are a critical matter in corporate management, encompassing both monetary and reputational risks. CFOs and accounting managers are therefore required to continuously manage and prevent their occurrence.

5. Characteristics and Points of Caution of Japan's Ancillary Tax System

Japan's ancillary tax system has several distinctive features compared to other countries.
First, the system is highly itemized. As mentioned, ancillary taxes in Japan are meticulously categorized by type, with applicable tax rates and relief measures varying depending on the case (e.g., under-declaration vs. non-filing). For example, while the U.S. has a uniform 5% per month penalty for late filing, Japan's additional tax for non-filing varies between 15% and 5% depending on whether it was a voluntary disclosure or not, reflecting a highly segmented application.

This implies that for Japanese taxpayers, "how they act" significantly changes the penalty, which can be seen as an incentive for taxpayers to voluntarily correct errors.

6. Key Points for Ancillary Tax Risk Avoidance

As various ancillary taxes can pose significant risks to businesses, it is crucial to implement preventive measures. Below are key points for CFOs and accounting managers of foreign-affiliated companies to practice for ancillary tax risk avoidance:

Ensure Proper and Timely Filing and Payment
The best course of action is to avoid under-declarations or late payments. Manage a tax calendar and establish a system to share and remind internal staff of various payment deadlines for corporate tax, consumption tax, withholding tax, social insurance premiums, etc. Also, establish internal controls, such as multi-person checks of filing content, to prevent errors.

Early Correction and Amendment
If an under-declaration or error is discovered, file an amended return or a late return as soon as possible. In Japan, ancillary taxes are reduced if corrections are made voluntarily before being pointed out in a tax audit.

Strengthen Internal Controls
Document internal rules regarding taxation and establish checklists and review systems. For routine tax operations, do not rely solely on the responsible staff member; it is important to have a system where supervisors or other personnel confirm deadlines and amounts.

Collaboration with Tax Professionals
Effectively utilizing external tax professionals, such as tax accounting firms or certified public tax accountant corporations, is also effective. Especially for foreign-affiliated companies unfamiliar with Japan's tax laws and practices, entrusting filing operations to a tax accountant can help avoid major mistakes and, if a problem arises, provide prompt and appropriate advice on countermeasures.

By implementing the above points, the risk of ancillary taxes can be significantly reduced. Foreign-affiliated companies, in particular, may initially find Japan's unique filing and payment practices confusing, but leveraging internal systems and professional networks to maintain compliance will ultimately lead to cost savings.

7. Strategic Responses Based on the Ancillary Tax System

While ancillary taxes should generally be avoided, a deeper understanding of the system can sometimes allow companies to reduce their burden. Below are some strategic responses based on the ancillary tax system:

Utilizing Special Provisions for Extension of Filing Deadlines
Companies can, by following prescribed procedures, extend the filing deadline for certain tax items, such as corporate income tax, by one month beyond the usual period. Avoiding a late filing situation through a filing deadline extension can prevent the imposition of additional tax for non-filing. It is important to note that only the filing deadline is extended, not the payment deadline.

Utilizing the Tax Deferral System
In cases where timely tax payment is difficult due to legitimate reasons such as worsening cash flow, disasters, or accidents, there is a system to apply to the tax office for temporary tax deferral. Since there are relief measures for delinquency tax during the deferral period, it is more advantageous than accumulating arrears without a plan.

By appropriately utilizing these systems, the imposition of ancillary taxes can be prevented or reduced in advance.
 

8. Conclusion

Japan's ancillary tax system encourages tax compliance through additional taxes and delinquency taxes. While the penalties vary by country, the common objective is to ensure proper filing and payment.

For CFOs and accounting managers of foreign-affiliated companies, an accurate understanding of each country's system and deadline management are key to risk avoidance. In Japan, specifically, ancillary taxes can be avoided by filing on time and responding conscientiously, making proactive measures and strengthened internal controls indispensable.

We hope that considering ancillary taxes will serve as an opportunity to review your company's tax risk management and implement necessary measures.

Contact us

Complete this form and an RSM Shiodome Partners representative will be in touch.