Key takeaways:

Simple icon of a blue lightbulb

Even routine business transactions, such as the conclusion of a loan agreement, may constitute a reportable arrangement subject to Mandatory Disclosure Rules (MDR).

Simple icon of a blue lightbulb

Whether a particular arrangement is reportable to the Head of the Polish National Revenue Administration is determined by the presence of the relevant hallmarks.

Simple icon of a blue lightbulb

The generic hallmarks may be broken down into two categories: those relating to the relationship between the relevant taxpayer and the intermediary (points (a) to (c)), and other generic hallmarks (points (d) to (h)).

On 1 January 2019, Poland implemented the provisions of the EU DAC6 Directive, imposing the obligation to report tax arrangements under the Mandatory Disclosure Rules (MDR) regime. Although the Polish MDR framework originally in force (until the end of September 2026) was broader in scope than the corresponding EU rules, numerous practical difficulties and interpretative uncertainties encountered by taxpayers ultimately prompted the legislative to amend the regulations and align them more closely with their underlying legal basis, namely the directive itself. How, therefore, should tax arrangements and their generic hallmarks be understood following the changes that took effect on 1 October 2026?

 

The role of hallmarks in tax arrangements

According to the definition found in the Polish Tax Ordinance, a tax arrangement is a cross-border arrangement that contains either a generic hallmark or a specific hallmark and concerns more than one Member State of the European Union (or a Member State of the European Union and a third country), provided that at least one of the following conditions is met:

  • not all participants to the arrangement are resident for tax purposes, incorporated, established or effectively managed in the same jurisdiction,
  • at least one participant to the arrangement is resident for tax purposes, incorporated, established or effectively managed in more than one jurisdiction,
  • at least one participant runs a business in another jurisdiction through a permanent establishment situated in that jurisdiction and the arrangement forms part or all of the business activities of that permanent establishment,
  • at least one participant carries out activities in another jurisdiction without being resident for tax purposes, incorporated or established in that jurisdiction and without having a permanent establishment there,
  • the arrangement may have an impact on the automatic exchange of information under the provisions governing the exchange of tax information with other jurisdictions or on the identification of a beneficial owner within the meaning of anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing regulations.

More specifically, a generic hallmark is a characteristic of an arrangement whereby, in addition to satisfying the main benefit test (MBT), at least one of the conditions set out in Article 86a(2)(8) of the Polish Tax Ordinance is met. Let us take a closer look at each of the eight generic hallmarks applicable to tax arrangements.

Generic hallmarks: when is satisfaction of the Main Benefit Test required?

Article 86a(2)(8)(a) – the relevant taxpayer or another participant to the arrangement has undertaken to comply with a confidentiality condition requiring that they do not disclose to other intermediaries or to the tax authorities how the arrangement is capable of securing a tax advantage.

The first of the generic hallmarks relates to confidentiality clauses and obligations of non-disclosure towards third parties, particularly other intermediaries or the tax authorities, regarding the manner in which the implementation of the arrangement enables the relevant taxpayer to obtain a tax advantage.

 

Article 86a(2)(8)(b) – the intermediary is entitled to receive a remuneration the amount of which is determined by reference to, or contingent upon, the amount of the tax advantage derived from the arrangement.

This generic hallmark covers success fee arrangements, under which the intermediary’s remuneration is linked directly to the anticipated tax advantage or one actually obtained through the implementation of the arrangement.

 

Article 86a(2)(8)(c) – the intermediary is entitled to receive remuneration contingent upon the obtaining of a tax advantage arising from the arrangement, or has undertaken to refund all or part of its remuneration where the anticipated tax advantage is not obtained or is obtained to a lesser extent than expected.

The next generic hallmark covers arrangements where, first, the payment of remuneration to the intermediary, or the retention of remuneration already received, is conditional upon the achievement of a tax advantage and, second, the expected tax advantage is either not obtained or is obtained in an amount lower than originally anticipated.

It should be noted that, in this context, it is irrelevant whether the agreement between the intermediary and the relevant taxpayer is entered into in written or oral form. Likewise, the method of settlement, including non-cash forms of consideration such as debt release, as well as the level of remuneration determined on a success fee basis, are of no significance.

 

Article 86a(2)(8)(d) – the transactions forming part of the arrangement rely on substantially standardised documentation or a substantially standardised structure that does not require material customisation for implementation by more than one relevant taxpayer.

This generic hallmark applies where the arrangement relies on documentation that is highly standardised and generally requires little or no modification prior to its implementation.

The implementation of such an arrangement should not necessitate significant additional actions or substantial adjustments on the part of the relevant taxpayer.

 

Article 86a(2)(8)(e) – deliberate actions are taken to acquire a loss-generating company, discontinue the core activity of such a company and utilise the losses of such a company in order to reduce tax liabilities, including by transferring these losses to an entity in the territory of another country or accelerating the utilisation of these losses.

The above generic hallmark describes a situation related to the acquisition of a company (this includes both a share deal and an asset deal) that meets two conditions:

  • it generates losses,
  • it may apply in the event of a cessation of operations and the utilisation of losses of such a company in order to reduce tax liabilities by, for example, accelerating the utilisation of these losses.

As a rule, the indicated hallmark will apply when the activities undertaken are aimed at achieving the goal specified in the above-mentioned provision.

 

Article 86a(2)(8)(f) – there is a change in the qualification of income (revenue) to another source of income (revenue) which effectively results in lower taxation, exemption or exclusion from taxation.

This generic hallmark may apply where the requalification of income or revenue results in any of the following outcomes:

  • a lower effective tax burden,
  • exemption from taxation,
  • exclusion from taxation.

However, as of 1 October 2026, this generic hallmark no longer covers situations where the arrangement results in a change to the applicable rules of taxation.

 

Article 86a(2)(8)(g) – the arrangement gives rise to circular flows of funds through the involvement of intermediary entities that do not perform any substantial economic functions, or involves transactions that offset or neutralise one another, result in substantially the same economic position as existed before the transactions were undertaken, or perform similar functions.

This generic hallmark may apply where:

  • the implementation of the arrangement requires the involvement of one or more intermediary entities that do not perform substantive economic functions, such as certain holding companies;
  • the transactions carried out as part of the arrangement offset or neutralise one another, or otherwise result in a position that is identical or substantially similar to that existing prior to the implementation of the arrangement, or perform comparable functions.

 

Article 86a(2)(8)(h) – the arrangement involves deductible cross-border payments made between associated enterprises where:
– the recipient is tax resident in a jurisdiction that either does not impose corporate income tax or imposes corporate income tax at a zero rate or at a rate not exceeding 1%,
– the payment benefits from a full tax exemption in the jurisdiction of residence of the recipient, or
– the payment is subject to a preferential tax regime in the jurisdiction in which the recipient is tax resident.

This hallmark relates specifically to cross-border arrangements. Its purpose is to expose arrangements designed to generate artificial tax advantages through deductible payments made between associated enterprises where the recipient benefits from very low or preferential taxation.

It should be noted that this hallmark may apply even where the payment is not made to a jurisdiction deemed engaging in harmful tax competition.

 

Generic hallmarks categorised 

The generic hallmarks applicable to tax arrangements may be divided into two principal categories:

  • hallmarks concerning the relationship between the relevant taxpayer and the intermediary, as set out in Article 86a(2)(8)(a)-(c) of the Polish Tax Ordinance,
  • other generic hallmarks, as set out in Article 86a(2)(8)(d)-(h) of the Polish Tax Ordinance

This distinction should, however, be regarded merely as a practical classification.

 

How can it be determined whether a given arrangement meets a generic MDR hallmark?

A sound understanding of the reportable arrangements framework and of the various hallmarks, both generic and specific, facilitates the assessment of whether a particular arrangement constitutes a reportable tax arrangement and is therefore to be disclosed to the Head of the National Revenue Administration.

It should be borne in mind that even the most routine commercial transactions may qualify as tax arrangements for MDR purposes. A common example is the conclusion of a loan agreement. Accordingly, taxpayers should approach MDR compliance with appropriate diligence and care. When assessing whether an arrangement satisfies a generic hallmark, a detailed analysis of the relevant provisions of the Polish Tax Ordinance is indispensable.

Given that individual tax rulings are not available in respect of MDR requirements and considering the potentially severe consequences of non-compliance, taxpayers should consider seeking advice from an experienced tax advisor when assessing their reporting obligations.